Diane Abbott’s remarks were shockingly generalised but held a truthful sentiment
Ok, ok. Hold the eggs. Refrain from pelleting the tomatoes just yet. Let’s joust and jostle a little. I just want you to see that Diane Abbott wasn’t all wrong.
For all of you who missed the true beloved splendour of Ms Abbott’s tweet a few days ago, she wrote: “White people love playing divide and rule”. The remark wasn’t nonchalant – the MP for Hackney North and Stoke Newington was involved in a string of comments with Bim Adewunmi, a freelance journalist, who was expressing her disregard for the term ‘black community’ and ‘black community leaders’.
Enter George Galloway, galloping to the rescue. He later tweeted, “Diane Abbott has been my friend for 25 years; only the obtuse would think her a ‘racist’”. By that theory most newspapers and commentators could be swept into the obtuse corner. The media had gone ablaze and so too did the front- and backbenches of the right-wing, all calling for Abbott’s resignation. Even Labour leader Ed Miliband called her on her mobile as she was mid-interview with a broadcaster.
But one must surely find some common ground with the remarks. Ms Abbott herself was born in 1953 in London to Jamaican immigrants – an island indiscriminately robbed of identity and language with the British’s arrival in the 17th Century.
A light-hearted ‘reading around the subject’ sends the mind racing. In the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province of Pakistan lies a city prominent for its pleasant weather, education standards and military establishments – going none other by the name Abbott-abad, named after Major James Abbott who founded the town, a mere one hundred years prior to the Hackney MP’s birth. There’s no denying, alongside her Cambridge History degree, her understanding of empirical Britain’s boorish behaviour in all those newfound lands.
Perhaps what made the tweet into a saga was the controversy already surrounding the sweet-talking Abbott. She got a lot of stick for sending her son James to the City of London School (an independent school, mind you) and for commenting on the ignorance about black people amongst her “blonde, blue-eyed Finnish girls” at her local hospital in east London.
It could be the acrimonious memories of what their ancestors perpetrated around the world that made the English jump with shock. The destructive potencies which coloured the world map – blue, green, yellow, orange and pink to signify their presence – were defiant to get the natives fighting each other than to join forces and rid their lands of these barmy, mostly pale-skinned newcomers.
In his recent book Ghosts of Empire, Conservative MP Kwasi Kwarteng blamed much of Africa’s present woes on the invasive presence of the imperialists. From the sugar plantations of the Caribbean to the golden coast of his native Ghana, there was definitely a bullish approach from the British. Ask any African immigrant old enough to recount first-hand (or maybe retell the stories of ancestors) the turbulent behaviour of the men who subdued them. Abbott’s comments, however, were far too generalised but we should be able to see the truth within them.